JOSS article text
-
My main critic point is that I am currently not quite sure how to get started with ELDAM. I like how the flowchart in the article outlines the process but it is not obvious how to do that in the API or in the GUI. I would recommend to add a small tutorial, either in the article or in the documentation which guides the user through a first cycle as shown in the flowchart. Doing this for the API and the GUI would help to tie the documentation parts together (see also #301 (closed)). -
I do not really understand the reason for the code in the article. It does not fit to the previous paragraph. Perhaps a subheader/paragraph explaining what the code should show is missing. -
Funding/Acknowledgements: please add the funding program / project number if available -
The article states "code has been used in various research projects" and then only cites one. Either put e.g. or state "has been used in research"
Edited by Gustave Coste